I don't know of any place to suggest. From my experience, these lodges are great to get away and be pampered with open bar, great food, etc but I never killed a big buck at the one I went to. Saw some decent bucks I never got a shot. Of course anything is possible and you may get lucky. Luck is the operative word at these places being at right place at right time just like hunting anywhere. Like I suggested, compare those two you mention, and any others that might come up, and figure out which caters best to a family with good food and a chance at decent buck. To me the only reason to hunt at a lodge/preserve is amenities and enjoyment of the facilities. Today, I'd only go for the quail hunting.