Some folks are getting hung up on the words and not looking at the math. A club with 5000 acres and only 15 members would likely cost you over $3000 to join. Under this model, you can join for $500. That seems like a steal.

Here's what I like about your model. Having a background in economics, I like the fact that those who consume more, pay more. Why should all members pay the same when some guys are trigger happy and some want to be selective? Killing more means paying more, that is an economically efficient way to do it. Having been in several clubs over the years, there's a perceived negative incentive. Some guys feel like they have to kill something or else they wasted money on a membership. This can lead to someone pulling the trigger on a deer they otherwise may not have shot, hence the negative incentive. This model somewhat addresses that because the dues are cheap unless you start killing a bunch.