If I was ging to run a club , I would be looking at recruiting trophy hunters and this is how I would try to run it . I would assign areas to hunt for each member. I would basically divide the tract up myself based on interior roads and terrain and I would assign areas and they could potentially cost diffrent amounts based on size and huntability, but I would try to keep it as even as possible to avoid this . But if you had a really good producing spot you could charge more for it .. If after straws were drawn the winner could pay for the good spot , or Pass it on to the next guy. I would be looking at keeping members for the long term . If a member wanted to allow someone to hunt there spot , it would be there choice . You could draw straws for the areas if you had a lot of members lined up at the beginning . You could also redraw straws for each season if you wanted , but this would be your choice , if you wanted to keep your area then you could .