POST-SEASON BOOT REVIEW:

I hunt a lot so these were put to the test.

Pros:
They never leaked. (Swamps, creeks, wet greenfields, rainy days) I had dry socks all season probably for the first time ever.
They were comfortable with practically no breaking in.
They look good.
They provided peace of mind.
They seem durable.
They do not slip up and down on your ankles.

Cons:
The cloth lining that covers the insole came loose around the toe area. It doesn't bunch up enough to bother me. I only noticed when I slipped them on barefoot.

I've recommended them to others who bought them and they really like them too. Overall, I'm very happy with the purchase and would buy them again.