Originally Posted By: M48scout
If absolutely knowing the number of deer present is require to make any decisions about deer management, every club out there should just chunk their Kill Book in the garbage, and every state agency in the country should just hang it up and go to the house. Might as well give up.

I'm sure you agree that we need some sort of overarching regulations to protect our resource? Given the complexity of our geography, land use, et. what should they base that on? Guesses? What Grandpa told them?


You don't have to know the exact number but you should have some idea as to the density of deer.

When you hunt an area, it doesn't take too long to figure out if the deer numbers are increasing, decreasing, or remaining about the same. You can't determine that just from harvest data. Many clubs today are very selective in what they kill. Harvest records won't tell the full story.

Of course we need regulations but even if all regulations were removed, I seriously doubt that the club I am in would change any of our rules.

I don't know what the right answer is. I see this as a possible step to get where we may need to be, but until someone can lay out a roadmap to where we are going, I will remain skeptical. It is a giant puzzle, but we only have or want some of the pieces. With so many clubs and private land owners being self regulated and with the State already controlling the WMAs, then I am wondering how useful will a game check system really be?