I really believe in the activated carbon clothing. I trust the science behind it and if they are making a fool out of me at least I'm more confident when going afield. I can say that since I bought my first full carbon suit two years ago I have tagged out both seasons. Prior to that I had only killed two bucks in the same season once. I cannot totally attribute that success to the cloth because I did start doing some other things different as well; but as a baseball guy, if I start swinging a new bat and go 4 for 4 Im gunna keep swinging that stick.
Regardless always hunt the wind and do what makes you confident. That always leads to better hunting IMO