Man this is tricky. You guys are all buddy's right? And deer huntin is about fun and enjoying time with buddys. If thats what you guys want a buddy club . And it sounds like you guys really get along excluding a short buck now and then. Id say leave it be and enjoy what you have . Or if you want a trophy club Make Rules Enforce them I ran a 12,000 acre club for 10 years we did 15" inside and 4 point on one side. First offence 100 per inch on spread and no hunting for 2 weeks. 2and time you get yer crap and go home for good.. I didn't enjoy hunting anymore and running that beautiful chunk of dirt got disgusting real fast. Its hard to be a buddy to everyone and raise good bucks. Now Im happy shooting deer just whatever I want to clean.