Originally Posted by Mbrock
Originally Posted by Hevishot13
Originally Posted by Mbrock
He’s 4 Atoler

You think so? I thought at least four, and I would entertain an idea of five. I trust you though.

You get in trouble trusting other folks. Lol.

Not having any history with the deer and given the location I’m saying 4. I’ve learned that with deer, just like people, there are norms and outliers. Most deer develop and mature following the standard we all go by. Outliers don’t. In any given age class there will be deer that just don’t fit the norm. Given the totality of info on him I say 4. He could be older but I doubt any younger.


Hopefully I will get to make a judgement call from the stand tomorrow evening. I always question myself on summer bodies. The wider deer with him is a year older. I’d be plenty happy with either, with my stick bow.

Here are a few other “older” deer from the same farm, for comparison.

[Linked Image]

[Linked Image]

[Linked Image]

[Linked Image]