Actually Mike, I think the hunting in AL is great. We have plenty of deer, a long and liberal season, and landowners get to choose how to manage their deer. I love hunting AL. There are some very nice bucks here, but they are harder to hunt and kill.
Great post Matt. Everything about hunting location is a tradeoff. Personally, I'll take hunting the tougher conditions and smaller deer of TN over anything in the Midwest because of what you said: much longer firearms season, much more liberal bag limits, and much more management freedom. I still have my childhood farm in southcentral KY to hunt, but I never hunt it. I
HATE hunting areas with very short gun season where every yahoo is in a tree for those few days a year. I prefer hunting longer with fewer hunters in the woods at one time, even if that means giving up buck size.